Will Rio Tinto and BHP Billiton Make It This Time? A Few Comments From The Perspective Of Antitrust Law

On 25 January 2010, European Commission said that it is ready to review a plan by the world’s second and third largest iron ore miners, Rio Tinto and BHP Biliton, to combine some iron ore mining operations in Australia. The European antitrust watchdog said that it would investigate whether the companies’ plan to pool iron ore mining in western Australia would affect the global prices or supply for iron ore transported by sea, known as seaborne iron ore. The Commission set no deadline for completion of the investigation, citing the complexity of the case, cooperation from the companies involved and exercise of the rights of defense, among other factors, to justify the open-ended time limit.

Continue Reading...

CIRC Published New Measures for Administrative Reconsideration of CIRC

Considering new problems generated in recent years, CIRC revised current Measures for Administrative Reconsideration of CIRC (hereinafter as “Old Measures”), and published the new one (hereinafter as “New Measures”). The New Measures has changed some significant aspects of procedures of administrative reconsideration and it will be effected from 1st of March.

Continue Reading...

Revised Provision On The Qualifications Of Directors, Supervisors And Senior Managers Of Insurance Companies Published

The new revised Provision on the Qualifications of Directors, Supervisors and Senior Managers of Insurance Companies was published by CIRC and it will be effected on 1st of April. It could be seen as a storm of supervision blowing from CIRC at the beginning of the year. This provision adjusts the scope and manners of CIRC’s qualification management system, strengthens the qualification of directors, supervisors and senior managers, and improves the long lasting supervision regulation.

Continue Reading...

The First Chinese Seller/Buyer Warranty And Indemnity Insurance Policy Is Underway

The Seller/Buyer Warranty and Indemnity Insurance is a new type of insurance in the global insurance market. The Purpose of this insurance is to against the risks involved in the M&A process, especially those risks generated by the misrepresentation of the parties. The insured target of the Seller/Buyer Warranty and Indemnity Insurance is the representation and warranty provision in the M&A contract. Differently put, the insured target should be the representation and warranty provision and related indemnification provision after breach of the contract.

Continue Reading...

Chinese Readers Upset Over No-Discount Rule

On January 8th, the China Publishers Association(中国出版工作者协会),the China Book Distribution Industry Association(中国书刊发行业协会)and the China Xinhua Bookstore Association(中国新华书店协会)(collectively the “Three Associations”) jointly published the “Book Fair Trade Rules” (“BFTR”). Its enactment generated widespread outcry at its suspected violation of China’s Anti-Monopoly Law (“AML”). BFTR became effective upon its release.

Continue Reading...

China Chapter:The International Comparative Legal Guide to: Cartels & Leniency 2010

 This article appeared in the 3rd edition of The International Comparative Legal Guide to Cartels and Leniency 2010; published by Global Legal Group Ltd, London(www.iclg.co.uk)

You can aslo download a bookmarked PDF version of this guide book at the following link:

http://www.iclg.co.uk/index.php?area=4&show_chapter=3380&ifocus=1&kh_publications_id=128

 1     The Legislative Framework of the Cartel Prohibition

1.1 What is the legal basis and general nature of the cartel prohibition, e.g. is it civil and/or criminal?

The principal legal basis for cartel prohibition is the Anti-Monopoly Law (AML) and the Price Law (Price Law). At the time of writing, two of China’s antitrust enforcement authorities—the State Administration for Industry & Commerce ( SAIC) and the National Development and Reform Commission (NDRC)—have also promulgated a series of implementing regulations for public comments: the Draft of the Regulations on Prohibiting Monopoly Agreements (SAIC) and the Draft of the Regulations on Prohibiting Price Monopoly (NDRC).

In China, violation of cartel prohibition carries administrative as well as civil liabilities. No criminal liability is provided for cartels in China.

Continue Reading...

Obligation on Explaining Exemption Clauses - An Ultimate Weapon to Insurance Companies

Exemption clauses are restrictions on the insurer’s insurance liability, and define the scope within which an insurer bears no liability to compensate or pay the insurance proceeds. Article 19 of new Insurance Law provides that the insurer shall, when concluding an insurance contract, provide on the application form, insurance policy document or other insurance certificate a reminder sufficient to draw the attention of the proposer to the exemption clauses in the insurance contract and shall expressly explain the contents of such clauses to the proposer in writing or orally. If no such reminder or express explanation is given, such clauses shall not enter into effect. The old Insurance Law provided a similar provision on this issue, but less practicable. This provision, in practical, has become an ultimate weapon to insurance companies. As of the occurrence of accident which is included in exemption clauses, lots insureds use this provision to claim their rights. They claim that the insurance company did not give them sufficient notice to draw their attention to the exemption clauses. The court, in practical, also adopts strict interpretation on these clauses to insurance companies.

Continue Reading...

Establishing Representative Office of Insurance Company in China (2)

Governmental supervision of financial industry is very strict in China. For CIRC’s examination of the foreign investors who want to establish representative office in its jurisdiction, the following documents shall be presented in front of CIRC: 
 

Continue Reading...

Will It Be A Death Sentence For Small Insurance Intermediaries?

The new Notification issued by CIRC may sentence the death of lots of small and medium- size insurance intermediaries.

On the last day of 2009, CIRC promulgated the Notification on Implementing the Supervision Regulation on Corporate Insurance Agency, the Supervision Regulation on Insurance Brokerage and the Supervision Regulation on Insurance Adjustment Institution (hereinafter referred to as three supervision regulations). According to this notification, the capital of all insurance intermediaries must reach the threshold provided on the three supervision regulations before October 1st, 2012.

Continue Reading...

Second Chinese "Abusing Dominant Market Position" Case Decided

On December 18, 2009, Beijing No.1 Intermediate People’s Court (the “Court”) reached a decision in favor of defendant in China’s second “abusing dominant market position” case.

BACKGROUND

The Plaintiff, Tangshan Renren Information Service Company (“TRISC”) operates an online platform that brokers deals between pharmaceutical companies and distributors and consumers. The Defendant, Baidu, which is allegedly the largest Chinese search engine company is accused of artificially lowering TRISC’s ranking in Baidu search results in order to coerce TRISC into continuing to purchase bid ranking service from Baidu. It is alleged to have caused TRISC to lose traffic and revenue. TRISC brought the case to the Court under Paragraph 1 of Article 17 of Chinese Anti-Monopoly Law (“AML”), namely, the exclusive dealing provision that prohibits a firm with market dominance position from restricting a third party to dealing with itself or selected third parties exclusively without valid justification. TRISC petitioned the Court to grant an order to enjoin Baido from the conduct and asked for $163,000 in damage for lost revenues. Baidu defended itself by arguing that lowering TRISC’s ranking in its search result was a response to the “junk links” practice TRISC engaged in, i.e. TRISC created a robot to automatically post junk posts on websites and forums and sent out spam messages to elevate its ranking in Baidu’s search results. According to Baidu, it adopts “anti-junk links” policy and made it sufficiently clear to the outside world by putting it on its website.

Continue Reading...